Fisher College of Business

About SIM

The Rosenfield Family Prize for Excellence in Security Analysis

The Rosenfield Family Prize for Excellence in Security Analysis is awarded each quarter to a graduate or undergraduate student at Ohio State University who develops the best security analysis report on a company each quarter. The prize targets students in the Student Investment Management (SIM) program of the Fisher College of Business, but it is open to all Ohio State University students. The report represents a professional-quality analyst report on the company developed independently by the student to justify an investment recommendation on the stock.

Autumn 2006
Rosenfield Prize winner Robert Blake (left) is congratulated for his report on Anheuser-Busch by SIM Director Andrew Karolyi (right).

It encompasses an executive summary of his or her recommendation (cover page) indicating a specific target price and target investment horizon for the stock investment as well as a detailed report offering an analysis of the position by outlining positives and negatives supporting the recommendation and a detailed analysis of the fundamental and technical valuation drivers and business and financial strengths of his or her company.

The report should be in the form of an executive memorandum and can be supported with charts, tables, and figures. A good report draws on many of the resources available to Ohio State University students, such as Thomson Financial’s StockVal, Datastream, Worldscope, IBES, FirstCall, Standard & Poor’s Compustat, Wharton’s Research Data Services, Reuter’s BridgeStation and Bloomberg. See the website of the SIM program for details. Electronic submissions are welcome. The report can be accompanied by the presentation slides used for the SIM class presentation. The report will not be judged by the investment outcome associated with the recommendation but by the quality of the exposition and analysis contained in the report.

Winter 2007
Rosenfield Prize winner Chad Zipfel proudly displays the award he received for his report on Wellpoint.

Students are invited to submit their reports by the end of the 9th week of each of each quarter. The awards will be made in the first week of the following quarter. Graduate and undergraduate students who have participated or are currently participating in SIM classes (Business Finance 724 or 824) are eligible to participate. A committee of faculty, students and external evaluators will judge the winners.

One $2,000 Excellence Award will be made to the top student report and one $500 Honorable Mention Awards will also be made to runners-up student reports.

The Rosenfield Family Prize for Excellence in Security Analysis is provided for by a generous gift to the SIM program by Ohio State University alumni Jack and Dan Rosenfield.

For more information, contact Professor Andrew Karolyi, Charles R. Webb Professor of Finance and Director, Student Investment Management Program, Fisher College of Business, Ohio State University, 814 Fisher Hall, Columbus, OH 43210-1144, (614) 292-0229, karolyi@cob.osu.edu.

Winter 2004 Inaugural
SIM Adjunct Professors Chris Henneforth (left) and Royce West (right) congratulating Rosenfield Prize winner from Autumn 2006, Constantine Elefter, for his report on Timken. Professor Anil Makhija (left), Finance department chairman, with SIM director Andrew Karolyi (right), congratulates Enoch Shih (center), Winter 2007 winner of the Rosenfield Prize for his report on Union Pacific Corp
Winter 2004 Inaugural
From left to right, Prof. Royce West , Fall 2005 Rosenfield Winners David Blocksom (1st Place), Sara Smith (2nd Place) and Prof. Andrew Karolyi . From left to right, Winter and Spring 2005 Rosenfield Winners: Jake Seegers, Rudy Priyetna, Prof. Andrew Karolyi, Prof. Royce West, Doug Harvey and Antonio Ferraro.
Winter 2004 Inaugural
Jack and Dan Rosenfield congratulate Sok Gun Song, MBA 2004, for his Winter-quarter prize-winning report on Alcoa, Inc, on May 13, 2004. Inaugural Rosenfield Prize Award recipient, Ronald A. Garrick, being congratulated by Prof. Andrew Karolyi and Dean Joseph Alutto.
Winners
Quarter Winner Report
Spring 2008 John Evans Conoco Phillips
Winter 2008 Evan Harding Motorola
Fall 2007 Mark Probst AEP
Summer 2007 Robert Blake Anheuser Busch
Spring 2007 Chad Zipfel Wellpoint
Winter 2007 Enoch Shih Union Pacific
Fall 2006 Constantine Elefter Timken
Summer 2006 Adam Grimes Valero Energy
Spring 2006 Tim Hanley Verizon Communications
Winter 2006 Ryan Hummer Walmart
Fall 2005 David Blocksom Staples
Summer 2005 Shaoyong Wang Lowes
Spring 2005 Doug Harvey Schlumberger
Winter 2005 Jacob Seegers Ball Corporation
Fall 2004 Brandon Seibert Citigroup
Summer 2004 Bhavik Kothari JP Morgan
Spring 2004 Steve Bright Abercrombie and Fitch
Winter 2004 Sok Gun Song Alcoa
Fall 2003 Ronald A. Garrick Capital One
 
The Ohio State University Fisher College of Business